Friday, April 26, 2019

Final Paper Topics

Due: Friday, May 10th
Length: 6 pages
Format: Argumentative, posing a thesis or question and offering sustained argument.
References: Use at least two sources from class and two outside sources.
Submit: Via email to justin@oursanctuary.org

1. Neolithic Economist Marshal Sahlins argued that hunter-gatherers remain the ‘original affluent society’ in the sense that their needs were easily met. Are these undeveloped peoples really wealthier than modern individuals? In your answer, explain what you mean by ‘wealth.’

2. Does evil exist? If so, what is it? If not, why should we deny its reality?

3. Do the activities of the CIA and the American Deep State contradict the belief that the US government is the leading edge of freedom and democracy? If not, in what sense are they consistent with that description?

4. In what sense is Climate Change an ethical question? How can it be understood as a question in distributive justice? What are our ethical obligations, and to whom do we owe them, regarding climate change and global ecocide generally?

5. Does climate change and related environmental challenges facing the human race require merely better energy technologies, or do these challenges call for a new ethics? If the latter, what ethical principles are required?

6. Does the present carry obligations towards the future? If so, how do we quantify the duties that presently existing peoples have to future generations?

7. In his essay “Buddhist Economics,” E. F. Schumacher argues that modern economics denies the inherent value of work. What have been the implications of this for how modern economies are structured and what might we do to create a system which values people?

8. Do the ethical principles of indigenous cultures differ significantly from the ethics of modern societies? If so, what are the relevant differences and which principles ought we to choose for our current circumstances?

9. The ethical principles of indigenous cultures, for example as described by Mohawk philosopher Clare Brant, reflect the different social and economic structures of traditional societies. How do these ethical principles rest on, and support these more traditional social and economic structures?

10. In her study of Ladakh, Helena Norberg Hodge argues that the root of all our key social and environmental problems is the global economy. Is she correct? If so, why? If not, why not? Explain and analyze her arguments.

11. Are human societies becoming less violent or more violent? Explore and analyze the relevant arguments for and against, including Four Arrow’s article from our class discussion.

12. In her study of dominator systems and partnership societies, Riane Eisler draws a distinction between two kinds of hierarchy: hierarchies of power, and hierarchies of actualization. What is the relevant difference between these two structures and how does the distinction help us understand the solution to equality between genders and/or classes?

13. Prison abolitionists argue for a restorative approach to justice to replace the adversarial model of justice currently institutionalized in what Mariame Kaba calls our “criminal punishment system.” How does this restorative model differ from our current carceral approach? What are some of the practices? What is its view of human relationship?

14. Are humans separate from each other or are they spiritually interconnected and inter-existent? What are the moral and social ramifications for how we answer this question?

15. Does civilization inevitably bring with it social inequality, violence and domination?

16. Have men always dominated western culture? If not, what evidence suggests the contrary?

17. Are Neolithic figurines evidence of a fertility cult or do they have a deeper meaningfor how we understand the possibilities for human culture?

18. What problems might be solved by adopting a new social guidance system based on partnership rather than domination?

19. Make up your own question but be sure to check it with me first.

20. What is forgiveness, and is it possible?

Good Luck Mighty Companion!

Thursday, April 11, 2019

4/16 Introduction to Riane Eisler's Study of Partnership Societies





With Special Guest Philosopher Jen Taylor

Reading for this class
Riane Eisler, The Chalice & The Blade, Introduction & Chapters 1-4.

Notes on Anti-Indianism in recent American Scholarship

§1. Four Arrows (Cherokee Philosopher) exposes anti-Indianism “so as to encourage more people to awaken to the perspectives about life that guided human behaviors for most of our history, before “God moved indoors,” to quote my old friend, Sam Keen”

§2. “The grim prognosis for life on this planet is the consequence of a few centuries of forgetting what traditional societies knew, and the surviving ones still recognize. We must nurture and preserve our common possession, the traditional commons, for future generations, and this must be one of our highest values, or we are all doomed. To regain this sensibility from those who have preserved it we must pay careful attention to their understanding and practices.” (Noam Chomsky, 2013)

A. The “Dances-with-wolves” approach to Native American history

§3. The Heart of Everything That Is: The Untold Story of Red Cloud, An American Legend (2013) by Bob Drury and Tom Clavin, given positive reviews by such prestigious and progressive publications as Salon and the Boston Globe which refer to the book’s “exceptional fairness and accuracy,” is a straight-forward example of gross anti-Indian bias, racism and fundamental misunderstandings about indigenous society and worldview and “the continued demeaning of Native Peoples, an approach that prioritizes Euro-centric people and values and ignores or dismisses the present by romanticizing or distorting the past.” (5)

§4. Red Cloud (Maȟpíya Lúta in Lakota, 1822-1909), Leader of the Oglala Lakota band, led successful military campaigns against the US army during Red Cloud’s War (1866-1868) in Wyoming and Montana, culminating in the Treaty of Fort Laramie (1868) which established the Great Sioux Reservation including Sioux ownership of the Black Hills, and set aside additional lands as unceded Indian territory in areas of South Dakota, Wyoming, and Nebraska, and possibly Montana. The treaty formed the basis of the 1980 Supreme Court case, United States v. Sioux Nation of Indians, in which the court ruled that tribal lands covered under the treaty had been taken illegally by the US government, and the tribe was owed compensation plus interest. As of 2018 this amounted to more than $1 billion. The Sioux have refused the payment, demanding instead the return of their land.

§5. Based on questionable scholarship by white historians who use a discredited white person’s unauthorized autobiography of Red Cloud; Uses the word “savage” repeatedly, widely used in the 19th century to describe Native peoples; Totally ignorant of the spiritual and historical meaning of the Black Hills (Paha Sapa) for the Lakota people; Dismisses Lakota tradition and history which holds that the Lakota lived in the Black Hills for centuries.

B. Lakota society was not patriarchal but rather matrilineal

§6. Calvin & Drury assert that the Lakota are not only patriarchal, but that “the “Sioux” men badly treated their woman who, according to the authors, were “closer to slaves than second-class citizens by modern standards of thinking” (p.65). But “Women controlled most of the tribe’s resources. When men married, they lived with the wife’s relatives. Women elders were highly respected and adult women had equal power in decision-making. The children belong to the mother’s clan. Today, in spite of the loss of language and culture and in spite of hundreds of years of anti-matrilineal propaganda, the Lakota women are still the backbone of the Lakota nation.” (7)

§7. “Women are missing-in-action in nearly all studies of Native America, whether historical, social or anthropological. I believe this is because westerners are still reacting to the panic that European patriarchs felt upon discovering Turtle Island chock-full of self-directed, articulate, and confident Native women, all demanding to be dealt with as equals. The initial Euro-male horror was frank and obvious in first-contact records and the recoil remains, skewing discussion.” (8)

§8. Birth of the women’s rights movement in the territory of the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Peoples in 1848 by Elizabeth Stanton, Matilda Joslyn Gage and Lucretia Mott.

C. Out-of-Context Emphasis on Warfare

§9. Supports the idea that war is natural part of humanity: “by applauding the Indian’s warrior traits while also picturing them as dirty, blood-thirsty, women-dominating savages, they show that this part of human nature, i.e. being war-oriented, proves that it is a good thing modern civilization took over.” (9)

§10. The development of western civilization as sufficient justification for genocide: “We did it for civilization” (10)

§11. Atrocities of American soldiers as temporary insanities versus the Indian’s inherent procivility towards violence, recalls Charles Mill’s point from The Racial Contract: Non-Europeans as savages, who live in the ‘wild.’ The classical social contract defines human beings by negation: we are the nonsavages, the ones who made it out of the ‘state of nature.’

§12. Peace as the default condition of traditional societies: “Peaceable preindustrial (preliterate, primitive, etc.) societies constitute a nuisance to most theories of warfare and they are, with few exceptions, either denied or “explained away.”

“The Original Affluent Society” by Marshall Sahlins in Stone Age Economics

§13. “Hunter-gatherers consume less energy per capita per year than any other group of human beings. Yet when you come to examine it the original affluent society was none other than the hunter's - in which all the people's material wants were easily satisfied. To accept that hunters are affluent is therefore to recognise that the present human condition of man slaving to bridge the gap between his unlimited wants and his insufficient means is a tragedy of modern times…”

§14. “There are two possible courses to affluence. Wants may be "easily satisfied" either by producing much or desiring little. The familiar conception, the Galbraithean way- based on the concept of market economies- states that man's wants are great, not to say infinite, whereas his means are limited, although they can be improved. Thus, the gap between means and ends can be narrowed by industrial productivity, at least to the point that "urgent goods" become plentiful. But there is also a Zen road to affluence, which states that human material wants are finite and few, and technical means unchanging but on the whole adequate. Adopting the Zen strategy, a people can enjoy an unparalleled material plenty - with a low standard of living. That, I think, describes the hunters. And it helps explain some of their more curious economic behaviour: their "prodigality" for example- the inclination to consume at once all stocks on hand, as if they had it made. Free from market obsessions of scarcity, hunters' economic propensities may be more consistently predicated on abundance than our own. Destutt de Tracy, "fish-blooded bourgeois doctrinaire" though he might have been, at least forced Marx to agree that "in poor nations the people are comfortable", whereas in rich nations, "they are generally poor”. 

Tuesday, April 9, 2019

Notes on Ladakh and the Ethics of Traditional Cultures

A. Thesis of Helena Norberg-Hodge’s study Ancient Futures

§1. The root of all key social and environmental problems: the global economy
climate change, loss of biodiversity and cultural diversity, shift from self-sufficient rural living to energy-intensive urbanism, communal belonging to consumerist image-making; monoculture commercialization of life promoting competition over cooperation, universalizable skills over local knowledge, individualism over community and consumerism over spirituality.

§2. Localism:  A strategy for resistance and renewal, a “solution multiplier” which “reduces our ecological footprint, increases biodiversity, provides fuller employment, strengthens democracy and rebuilds community.” (xxi); not total communal self-reliance but rather “shortening the distance between producers and consumers whenever possible, and striking a healthier balance between local markets and a monopoly-dominated global market.” (xxi)

B. Themes from the study of indigenous societies (Helena Norbert Hodge, Ecologist)

§3. Health – holistic (restoring balance) vs reductive (controlling symptoms)

Almost everyone is fit and trim; The old are active until the day they die (37); very low stress, toxin-free, optimal diet lifestyle (39); Holistic energy medicine treats disease as imbalance; mental health issues are non-existent (41)
No sense of pride (rooted in insecurity) in the Ladakhis, e.g. the example of the man ordered around by the kids in the truck (84-85); the mindfulness of the Ladakhis (86). 

§4. Justice – restorative & DIY (focus on relationships) vs retributive, job of the state, focused on damages to individuals

Cultural focus on peace and non-violence, not expressing anger; “no fighting in the village in living memory” (46); the phenomenon of the “spontaneous intermediary” (47-48); Human scale villages (less than 100 houses), everyone knows everyone and is dedicated to “living together” (51)

§5. Social structures – egalitarian & heterarchical (matricentric) vs stratified & hierarchical (patriarchal)

Minimal disparities in wealth, 95% of population in the middle class; destroyed by monetary economy (103); Democratic/consensus politics for collective decision-making, the representative for each village council (goba) appointed by rotation. (49)

Flexible marriage relationships to fit into land constraints (from monogamy to polyandry to polygyny) (55)
No word in Ladakhi for romantic love. 

Child- rearing: unlimited and unconditional affection (66) but it does not lead to children being spoiled, just the opposite; kids with great responsibilities (66)

Parity of gender: women have lots of power (68); flexible gender roles in work and parenting

§6. Trade/Economy – gift-based, focused on group cohesion (principle of socialism) vs money-based, focused on individual consumption (capitalism)

Self-sufficient farms owned by individual families, a steady-state local economy designed to fit within the ecological limits to population growth. 

Agriculture as resilient, nature-based, self-sufficient vs “efficient”, hydrocarbon-based, and specialized for export

Private property (incl. land, houses, tools and animals) and labor which are shared. (53). But ownership in usufruct (stewardship) (58)

§7. The word "community" is derived from the Old French communité which is derived from the Latin communitas (com, "with/together" + munus, "gift"), a broad term for fellowship or organized society. 

“Community is woven from gifts. Unlike today's market system, whose built-in scarcity compels competition in which more for me is less for you, in a gift economy the opposite holds. Because people in gift culture pass on their surplus rather than accumulating it, your good fortune is my good fortune: more for you is more for me. Wealth circulates, gravitating toward the greatest need. In a gift community, people know that their gifts will eventually come back to them, albeit often in a new form. Such a community might be called a "circle of the gift.””  
Money creates separateness, can be hoarded and controlled, is quantified, promotes individualism and independence and selfish behavior. Gifting creates relationship, promotes cycling, is democratic, promotes community cohesion and self-full (vs. self-ish behavior (i.e. a more expansive experience of self.  

§8.  Worldview – spiritual with a basis in shared identity vs materialistic with a basis in separate identity

Buddhism woven into the fabric of life - the philosophy of interdependency versus individualism (75); reverence for nature, praying to the spirits of water and earth before sowing seeds. (19) Thanking animals for their lives (31)
Time: not commodified but based on natural cycles (35)
Nature as a living, conscious, sacred and intelligent being (Pachamana) vs. a non-living, non-intelligent mechanism which can be understood objectively.

(C) Native Ethics & Principles (Clare Brant, Mohawk Philosopher)

§10. The Ethic of Non-Interference • That is the principle that one Indian will never tell another Indian what to do. It is considered rude behaviour to give instructions or orders to another Native person. That’s quite different from the white society. Two white men at a cocktail party – say they’re standing there side by side – and if one of them announces he wishes to buy a pear tree another white man will immediately suggest that he buy a peach tree instead. In the white society the one who can out-advise the other is one up, and the loser is expected to take his defeat with good grace. Now in the Indian society, this is not permitted. Advising or instructing, or ordering or persuading, is always considered bad form or behaviour.

§11. The Anger Must Not Be Shown Principle • This also is a very widespead and very widely practised behaviour. It seems to have had its origin again in the Aboriginal society, in which there were shamans and witches about all over the place. And one dared not show one’s temper because these shamans and witches could cast a spell on you, put the bothers on you if you insulted or offended them, or showed them your temper.

§12. The Indian Concept of Time • Time is, to an Indian, something which must be used and enjoyed. One does not move onto something else until one has finished what one is doing. It seems to have had its origin – again I have to say “seems to” because we don’t have precise information – in that activities of Indians used to be regulated by the seasons, by the sun, and by the migratory patterns of birds and animals; a changing food supply, absence of electricity and hydro power, so they had to be dependent upon the seasons and nature to supply them with food, with light and all kinds of things. And having learned to live in harmony with nature and relevance to these things, the concept of “doing things when the time is right” came into play – which is still in play today. 

§13. Principle that Everything Is Shared • All the assets and resources of a community or of a family, or of the extended family, are shared and one is supposed to take no more than what one needs from the environment, than one needs to survive. To take more to waste is bad. To take more than one’s fair share or more than what one actually needs to survive is considered greedy and wasteful. This is one of the greatest of all the Native ethics and it’s universal. It could have had its origin in the need to show hospitality to wandering hunters even though there was not much food in the village. The hunters from another group, another family, or another clan, must be fed in order that they would take food back to their own people. That may have been the origin of it. But the principle is survival of the whole group over individual prosperity and individuality. This is the principle of Marxism, the principle of all socialism, and alleged to be the principle of Christianity as well. The Native people do not use it as a political ideology or as a religion; it is acted out as the way Native people live. The ethic of sharing has its corollaries, which are equality and democracy.

5. The Attitude to Gratitude • Gratitude among Native people is very rarely shown; it’s very rarely verbalized. One is not rewarded for being a good teacher, doctor, farmer, fisherman, hunter, because that is what you are supposed to be. If you are trained to be a nurse you should be a good one. To be less than perfect would be a bad thing for you to be. You would not be developing the best part. So that if you do a good job, that’s fine, you are not going to be thanked for it. To be thanked for it would be superfluous because doing a good job has its own intrinsic reward. Gratitude eventually is shown at the end of a long life. If one keeps one’s nose clean and does a good job, and one is perceived and regarded as a wise and venerable person, this is the greatest reward of all. 

7. Now the Teaching; Shaping Vs. Modeling • This is a more technical kind of thing. The white people use this method of teaching their children – it’s called ‘shaping’. Whereas the Indians use ‘modelling’. Shaping is B.F. Skinner’s ‘Operant Conditioning”, if you want to look into that one. Say a white person is teaching a white kid how to dress – he uses the shaping method, one way being “rewarding successive approximations” of the behaviour he wants. When we asked Josh, a reknowned hunter, how his father taught him to hunt. He said, “He didn’t teach me.” Well, that’s ridiculous, everybody has to be taught everything. The people and father in the hunting modelled hunting behaviour, and then suddenly, “Okay, you’re ready to do it, and you can do it forever.”

9. The Dependence-Independence Ethic • It might seem that because the Indian people live on welfare that they are very dependent people. This is again the furthest thing from the truth. Native people are the most independent minded people I’ve ever seen. One is expected to look after oneself, take one’s own council and not be told what to do by other people; make up your own mind about everything, listen to advice but not follow it very precisely, incorporate it into what you know is right, and go on from there.



10/16 Philosophy of Money and Banking

Texts for this class (1)  HR6550 Bill to Reform the Banking Industry (2)  "Beyond Greed & Scarcity: An Interview with Be...