Wednesday, March 13, 2019

3/14 Intergenerational Justice and the Case for Reparations



Text for this class
Ta-Nehisi Coates, "The Case for Reparations"

Notes on Angela Davis and Prison Abolition


How does the U.S. criminal justice system create and maintain racial hierarchy through mass incarceration? 

How does the current system of mass incarceration in the United States mirror earlier systems of racialized social control?

What is needed to end mass incarceration and permanently eliminate racial caste in the United States?

What would a society without the need for prisons look like?


A. Some Facts about Race and Mass Incarceration

1. We imprison more people than any other country.
2. The U.S. has over 2.4 million behind bars, an increase of over 500% in the past thirty years
3. We have 5% of the world’s population; 25% of its prisoners
4. People of color represents 60% of people in cages
5. One in eight black men in their twenties are locked up on any given day
6. Lifetime likelihood of a white man being incarcerated: 1 in 17
7. Lifetime likelihood of a black man being incarcerated: 1 in 3
8. Black men are 6.5% of US population and 40.2% of incarcerated population
9. 75% of people in state prison for drug conviction are people of color although blacks and whites see and use drugs at roughly the same rate. In NYS, 94% of those imprisoned for a drug offense are people of color.
10. The number of drug offenders in state prison has increased thirteen-fold since 1980
11. 5.3 million Americans are denied their right to vote
12. Over the past two decades, state spending on prisons grew six times the spending of higher education

B. The Ideological Work that Prisons Do (Are Prisons Obsolete, p.16)

C. Similarities of Prisons to Slavery (27)

1. Convict leasing system + debt peonage sharecropping as continuation of slavery.
2. The 13th Amendment does not abolish slavery as such but only one kind of slavery.
3. Imputing Crime to Color - criminalizing black behaviors to supply black bodies for exploitation - Court House replaces the Lynch mob
4. Nixon: the drug problem as a crime problem versus mental health problem
5. Tough on Crime Democrats: TheClinton/Biden 1994 Omnibus Crime Bill - Truth in Sentencing Law, Mandatory Minimum serving 85% sentences, doing away with parole in the Federal System, 100,000 new police, Militarization of Local Police Departments, Ends Pell Grants for Prison Ed


D. Development of Modern Prisons as Human Alternative to Capital Punishment and Public Torture (48)

1. Protestant Reformers and “penitentiaries” - the morally dubious status of solitary confinement. 
2. Women don’t need prisons, their husbands punish them.
3. Rise of the Supermax and “F-Type” Prisons - replace reform with “incapacitation” - exported by the US, king of the global incarceration system.

If the original moral argument for prisons has been refuted (the rehabilitative function of solitary confinement), then are prisons morally and socially obsolete?

E. Women in Prison 

“Most Invisible Population:” the single most vulnerable, most traumatized, and most at risk demographic in the country: Incarcerated Women of Color, the fastest growing segment of the US prison population. From 1997 to 2007 the number of women in prison has increased by 832%. 

Sexual violence as a tool of repression (strip search)

F. Prison-Industrial Complex (vs. prison system) (84)

1. The PIC as reproducing the conditions of its own expansion, creating a syndrome of self-perpetuation

2. Connection of capitalism, racism and incarceration - neoliberal destruction of social welfare nets, undermining economic democracy, desperation creating justification for incarceration; 3. Connections between criminalization of young blacks, immigrants and global capitalism. Immigration as caused by the ‘homelessness of global capital.

3. Private prison companies are striking deals with states that contain clauses guaranteeing high prison occupancy rates–sometimes 100 percent. This means that states agree to supply prison corporations with a steady flow of residents–whether or not that level of criminal activity exists. [ITPI Report 2013]

4. The federal prison industry produces 100 percent of all military helmets, ammunition belts, bullet-proof vests, ID tags, shirts, pants, tents, bags, and canteens. Along with war supplies, prison workers supply 98 percent of the entire market for equipment assembly services; 93 percent of paints and paintbrushes; 92 percent of stove assembly; 46 percent of body armor; 36 percent of home appliances; 30 percent of headphones/microphones/speakers; and 21 percent of office furniture. Airplane parts, medical supplies, and much more: prisoners are even raising seeing-eye dogs for blind people. [http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/21694-shocking-facts-about-americas-for-profit-prison-industry]

We are not looking for prisonlike substitutes for the prison, such as house arrest safeguarded by electronic surveillance bracelets. Rather, positing decarceration as our overarching strategy, we would try to envision a continuum of alternatives to imprisonment - demilitarization of schools, revitalization of education at all levels, a health care system that provides free physical and mental care to all, and a justice system based on reparation and reconciliation rather than retribution and vengeance.  
                                                               Angela Davis, Are Prisons Obsolete? 

For more information check out the 

Thursday, March 7, 2019

More Notes on Charles Mills’ The Racial Contract and White Supremacy

A. Establishing Personhood & Sub-personhood based on the contract of race
§1. Resolves Aristotle’s problem “For that which can foresee by exercise of the mind is by nature intended to be lord and master, and that which can with its body give effect to such foresight is a subject, and by nature a slave; hence master and slave have the same interest.” However, “Nature would like to distinguish between the bodies of freemen and slaves… but the opposite often happens - that some have the souls and others have the bodies of freemen.” (Politics)

§2. The racial contract est. a particular “somatotype as the norm, deviation from which unfits one for full personhood and full membership in the polity.” (54) personhood defined as a negation of subpersonhood. “Superiority is the logic or the glue for the grouping. This is not to say that members of the group are in fact superior intellectually, physically or otherwise, but rather, that superiority served as the reason to justify the creation of the group.” (Jacqueline Battalora, Birth of a White Nation, 90-91.)

B. Implications of Citizenship Status
§3. The first meeting of the US Congress in 1790 determined that in order to become a naturalized citizen, one had to be white (Act of March 26, 1790, ch.3, Stat. 103). The requirement of establishing that one was white for the purpose of naturalization was the law of the land until its repeal in 1952 (8 U.S.C. § 1422). The protections that citizenship brings: civil, political, and social rights. 

Civil rights: enable individual freedom, such as liberty of the person, freedom of speech and religion, intellectual pursuit, the right to contract and to own property, and the right to justice.
Political rights: the right to engage in the political process, either as a member of the political body or an elector of those who make up that body.
Social rights: a wide range including a measure of economic welfare and security, the right to fully participate in the social heritage and to a civilized life as measured by the prevailing social standards.

C. Whiteness connected to exploitive capitalism 
§4. Noncitizens excluded from citizenship (i.e., nonwhite) were denied all but low-wage jobs and difficult conditions. Each exclusion and limitation placed upon nonwhites via the white-only requirement in naturalization law created value for whites, white men in particular, including: access to more land at better prices (via the exclusion of large populations of potential buyers), less competition for skilled jobs, generally more desirable jobs, less competition for advancement within all levels of society, greater access to education and training, and a more influential voice in the body politic.

- Used to exploit Chinese laborers (in 1882 with the Chinese Exclusion Act)
- Mexicans defined as ‘conditional whites’ by the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo (1848) after the Mexican-American War, classified as white by the Federal Government by not by Texas or other states. Only Mexicans of with wealthy Spanish lineages considered white. 
- The 1.8 million Irish who came in the ten-year span between 1845 and 1855, many fleeing starvation in Ireland, originally considered non-white or ‘white negros;’ end up being classified as white in order to build the Democratic Party (Martin Van Buren and then Andrew Jackson) removing the requirement of property ownership as a prerequisite to vote.

D. Whiteness as Cultural Norm: A Standard of beauty and goodness
§5. The white body as the somatic norm image, “deviation from which triggers alarms.” White privilege includes the privilege of having the ideals of human perfectibility encoded in images that look like you. Malcolm X called this out in bold clarity, in his Autobiography: “This was my first really big step toward self-degradation: when I endured all of that pain, literally burning my flesh to have it look like a white man’s hair. I had joined that multitude of Negro men and women in America who are brainwashed into believing that the black people are ‘inferior’ - and white people ‘superior’ - that they will even violate and mutilate their God-created bodies to try to look ‘pretty’ by white standards.

E. The Racial Contract as being continually re-written: From de jure to de facto white supremacy
§6. Phase 1 de jure white supremacy - expropriation contract: “Manifest Destiny” against lazy savages who don’t develop the land; slave contract, non-whites as morally incapable of self-rule. “Kill the Indian, but save the man.” (88).

§7. Phase II de facto white supremacy - the racial contract writes itself out of formal existence; ongoing tension between continuing de facto privilege and formal extension of rights of nonwhites. (E.g. Jim Crow Laws and Black Codes, The racial caste system which operated primarily, but not exclusively in southern and border states, between 1877 and the mid-1960s. A black male could not offer his hand (to shake hands) with a white male because it implied being socially equal. Obviously, a black male could not offer his hand or any other part of his body to a white woman, because he risked being accused of rape. Blacks and whites were not supposed to eat together. If they did eat together, whites were to be served first, and some sort of partition was to be placed between them.  Under no circumstance was a black male to offer to light the cigarette of a white female -- that gesture implied intimacy; De facto slavery continues after the Civil War: Vagrancy laws, onerous labor contracts, criminalize self-sufficiency while attacking blacks as lazy, Convict leasing system + debt peonage sharecropping as continuation of slavery. 

F. White Backlash against Civil Rights Era 
§8. Begins with Brown vs. Board of Education (1954): Supreme Court, esp. Thurgood Marshall, rules that Jim Crow schooling violates 14th and 5th amendments; Racism trumps even education for poor whites - Mississippi abolishes its public system to avoid integration; Nixon and Reagon redefine what the Civil Rights Movement was about ( bus seats and water fountains and not multigenerational plunder); slavery (the best thing that ever happened to blacks - Patrick Buchanan; Nixon’s “Southern Strategy” - painting the Democratic Party as the party of African Americans; creating social chaos by inducing unreasonable expectations in blacks for equality; weakening the enforcement of the Voting Rights Act 1965; Reagan’s “plausible deniability racism” - radicalizes social welfare, guts the social welfare system; fewer blacks enrolled in college in 1980s than in the 1970s; orders layoffs in federal employment - cumulatively, “by 1990 blacks in the bottom 20% were poorer in relation to whites than at any time since the 1950s.

G. Racial Contract enforced through violence and ideology
§9. The liberal-democratic state of the social contract: based on consent of the governed and neutral with respect to the lives of its citizens vs the racial polity of the racial contract as imposed through violence, (nonconsensual) and not neutral 

§10. Imposing white supremacist ideology on nonwhites. (83) - the significance of lynching and anti-black police violence, mass incarceration; Origins of the Black Panther Party: “Huey suggested … that we bring these brothers off the block, openly armed, on the campus and bring the press down. We could reach the community and show them that Malcolm X has advocated armed self-defense against the racist power structure and show the racist white power structure that we intend to use guns to defend the people.” - from Bobby Seale, Seize the Time: The Story of the Black Panther Party and Huey P. Newton, p. 30-31.

H. The Racial Contract creates a radicalized moral psychology: Evasion, Self-deception and Fragility   
§11. Dropping a culture bomb on nonwhites: “If the social contract req. that all citizens and persons learn to respect themselves and each other,  the Racial Contract prescribes nonwhite self-loathing and racial deference to white citizens.” (89) The need to justify one’s superiority by degrading the other: “It is impossible for us to suppose these creatures to be men, because, allowing them to be men, a suspicion would follow that we ourselves are not Christians.” (Montesquieu quoted by Mills, p. 97)

§12. “How can U.S. culture and society be altered when the roots of white supremacy are foundational as a matter of history and law? How can a group of people invented in part through the assertion that they are more deserving of rights and privileges than others be transformed? Is it possible to take something conceived out of superiority and deployed as a wedge between American laborers, and make it humane and fair?”
“Whites will act in racist ways while thinking of themselves as acting morally. In order words, they will experience genuine cognitive difficulties in recognizing certain behavior patterns as racist, so that quite apart from questions of motivation and bad faith they will be morally handicapped…” (93) E.g. failure to denounce crimes, downplaying suffering of nonwhites, “national web of self-deception” (97), exaggerated alarm at nonwhite violence against whites.


§13. “White people in this country will have quite enough to do in learning how to accept and love themselves and each other, and when they have achieved this—which will not be tomorrow and may very well be never—the Negro problem will no longer exist, for it will no longer be needed.”  James Baldwin

Tuesday, March 5, 2019

Notes on Charles Mill’s The Racial Contract


“White Supremacy is a political system, a particular power structure of formal or informal rule, socioeconomic privilege, and norms for the differential distribution of material wealth and opportunities, benefits and burdens, rights and duties.”

(A) Racism as a Political System: White Supremacy

Race is the child, not the parent, of racism. 
- Ta-Nehisi Coates

1. Race as a social construction. The term ‘race’ - problematic due to its biological reference, derived from a breeding line or stock of animals whose qualities are inheritable genetically. Essentialism (racial categories as derived from nature) versus social constructivism (racial categories as derived from human choices)

2. Racism as white supremacy isn’t an act, it is a system. Racism is not the same thing as prejudice. Everyone is socialized to have prejudices - to treat people perceived as different differently. Racism is prejudice backed by the power of legal authority and institutional control, that “functions independently from the intentions or self-images of individual actors.”

3. “The direction of power between white people and people of color is historic, traditional, and normalized in ideology. Racism differs from individual racial prejudice and racial discrimination in the historical accumulation and ongoing use of institutional power and authority to support the prejudice and to systematically enforce discriminatory behaviors with far-reaching effects. People of color may also hold prejudices and discriminate against white people, but they lack the social and institutional power that transforms their prejudice and discrimination into racism.”

- Ten richest Americans: 100% white
- US Congress: 90% white
- US governors: 96% white
- Top military advisors: 100% white
- People who decide which TV shows we see: 93% white
- Owners of professional football teams: 97% white
- The median White family now has 41 times more wealth than the median Black family and 22 times more wealth than the median Latino family... Since 1983, median wealth for all U.S. households declined by 3 percent, adjusting for inflation. Over this same period, the median Black family saw their wealth drop by more than half."

(B) The Racial Contract

4. “Instead of pretending that the social contract outlines the ideal that people tried to live up to but which they occasionally failed (as with all ideals) fell short of, we should say frankly that for whites the Racial Contract represented the ideal, and what is involved is not deviation rom the (fictive) norm but adherence to the actual norm.” (p. 57- all references to The Racial Contract)).

5. Political Contract: 
An account of the origins of government and our political obligations
(a) as a contract which establishes society (taking individuals out of the ‘state of nature’
(b) as establishing the state (transferring power to a governing entity)

6. Moral Contract: 
An account of the founding of the moral code which regulates the behavior of citizens.  

7. Racial Contract:  Political, Moral and Epistemological - “that set of formal and informal agreements… which set the limits of the contracts’ validity between the members of one subset of humans as ‘white’ and another subset as ‘non-white’ and of a different and inferior moral status. (p.11) 

  • Not a contract between whites and non-whites, but an agreement among those “categorized as whites over the nonwhites, who are thus the objects rather than the subjects of the agreement.” (12)
  • An agreement which actually constructs race, ‘invents the white race for the first time.” (63)

(C) The Legal Creation of “White people” 

8. The label “white” reflecting a group of humanity appears nowhere in law until 1681. It first appears in an enactment passed by the Colonial Assembly of the Colony of Maryland, an antimiscegenation law which criminalized interracial marriage. It punished a “white” woman or man who married a person who was of African descent or a member of a native tribe by banishing them from the colony.

9. Did racism cause slavery or slavery cause racism? Freemen of Africa descent could and did marry British white men, own land, and vote, run for office, during this pre-Black code era. Edmund Morgan states that colonists in Virginia during the 1660s and 1670s were “ready to think of Negroes as members or potential members of the community on the same terms as other men and to demand of them the same standards of behavior” (1975: 155). Furthermore, it is noteworthy that marriage among those of African descent, mostly men, and those of European descent, mostly women, were not unusual and appear to have been met with acceptance (Smedley 2007: 105). The body of historical evidence suggests that slavery did not emerge as a result of widespread British animosity and hostility toward Africans because of their skin color.

10. The “racial bribe”. Bacon’s Rebellion: In 1676, discontented people erupted in the colony of Virginia with laborers of European and African descent, bond and free, uniting in the fight against unpaid labor, the plantation elite, and those governing the colony, in an effort to realize greater opportunity and independence. Colonial Administrators consciously imposed a divide-and-conquer strategy, known as the “racial bribe” to split the laborers against each other. 

11. Legal Creation of Racism to support slavery. In rapid succession Afro-Americans lost their right to testify before a court, to engage in any kind of commercial activity, either as buyer or seller; to hold property; to participate in the political process; to congregate in public places with more than two or three of their fellows; to travel without permission; and to engage in legal marriage or parenthood

12. The Virginia Slave Codes of 1705 were a series of laws enacted by the Colony of Virginia's House of Burgesses regulating activities related to interactions between slaves and citizens of the crown colony of Virginia. The enactment of the Slave Codes is considered to be the consolidation of slavery in Virginia, and served as the foundation of Virginia's slave legislation.
These codes effectively embedded the idea of white supremacy into law by the following devices:
  • Established new property rights for slave owners
  • Allowed for the legal, free trade of slaves with protections granted by the courts
  • Established separate courts of trial
  • Prohibited blacks, regardless of free status, from owning arms [weapons]
  • Whites could not be employed by blacks
  • Allowed for the apprehension of suspected runaways

(D) Norming and racing of space / demarcating civil and wild

13. Space, taken for granted as just there for the adult white male, is created by the racial contract. “You are what you are in part because you originate from a certain kind of space, and that space has those properties in part because it is inhabited by creatures like you.” (42)

14. Non-Europeans as savages, who live in the ‘wild.’ The classical social contract defines human beings by negation: we are the nonsavages, the ones who made it out of the ‘state of nature.’

15. European civilization as a planetary-evolutionary process, not just a part of the world, but the advancing frontier of civilization at the microlevel (continents and nations), local level (city neighborhoods), and microlevel (the nonwhite body). (43-44)

16. The epistemological dimension of norming - Restriction of knowledge of European cognizers; true cultural achievement and progress as white, nonwhite culture as permanently locked into superstition and ignorance.
E.g. The European “discovery” of the New World (45)

17. Moral dimension of norming - The inherent moral depravity of non-European space E.g. the Dark Continent, the Inner City, the Nonwhite Body. (51)


(E) Establishing Personhood & Sub-personhood 

18. The racial contract est. a particular “somatotype as the norm, deviation from which unfits one for full personhood and full membership in the polity.” (54) personhood defined as a negation of subpersonhood.

19. Answers Aristotle’s problem by defining servile and non servile beings; defines subperson somatically, in terms of deficient rationality; 

E.g.  Heathen unwillingness to recognize God’s word (59),  American slavery system,  Jim Crow laws invalidating black testimony in courts, cultural racism in testing where nonwhites show themselves incapable of mastering White culture (61); aesthetic somatic norms which identify whiteness with beauty. 


(F) The Racial Contract justifies the European conquest of the world, underwrites the social contract

20. All modern social contract theorists are white supremacists. 64-72

21. European colonization of the third world: the ‘expropriation contract’ (Locke): “God gave the world to the use of the Industrious and Rational.” (67)


(G) The Racial Contract as being continually re-written: From de jure to de facto white supremacy

22. Phase 1 de jure white supremacy - expropriation contract, slave contract, colonial contract

23. Phase II de facto white supremacy - the racial contract writes itself out of formal existence; ongoing tension between continuing de facto privilege and formal extension of rights of nonwhites. 73

24. Naziism as an attempt to turn the clock back to more exclusivist version of the racial contract (78)

(H) Racial Contract enforced through violence and ideology

25. The liberal-democratic state of the social contract: based on consent of the governed and neutral with respect to the lives of its citizens vs the racial polity of the racial contract as imposed through violence, (nonconsensual) and not neutral - imposing white supremacist ideology on nonwhites. (83)

26. “…if in the racial polity nonwhites may be regarded as inherently bestial and savage (quite independently of what they happen to be doing at any particular moment), then by extension they can be conceptualized in part as carrying the state of nature around with them, incarnating wildness and wilderness in their person.” (87)

Dropping a culture bomb on nonwhites: “If the social contract req. that all citizens and persons learn to respect themselves and each other,  the Racial Contract prescribes nonwhite self-loathing and racial deference to white citizens.” (89)


(I) The Racial Contract creates a radicalized moral psychology

27. “Whites will act in racist ways while thinking of themselves as acting morally. In order words, they will experience genuine cognitive difficulties in recognizing certain behavior patterns as racist, so that quite apart from questions of motivation and bad faith they will be morally handicapped…” (93)


E.g. failure to denounce crimes, downplaying suffering of nonwhites, “national web of self-deception” (97), exaggerated alarm at nonwhite violence against whites, inability to place the Jewish Holocaust in its larger context.

Thursday, February 28, 2019

3/5- 3/7 Philosophy of Racism and White Supremacy





Text for these classes
Charles Mills, The Racial Contract

Notes on the Philosophy of Money and Banking


Money as a Flawed Technology 

Is money a thing(commodity) or is it an agreement(IOU)?

How does the use of different kinds of money affect the moral relationships between people?

Can morality be defined economically in terms of debt, what we owe each other?

Are we ethically-obligated to pay back our debts?

Is there an essential systemic connection between monetary systems and violence?

What is usury, and is it a sin?

Is global debt peonage a justifiable result of monetary systems or an ethical abomination?

Should commercial banks have the power to issue new money?

Should the FED be nationalized?

Should there be a global debt jubilee?


10/16 Philosophy of Money and Banking

Texts for this class (1)  HR6550 Bill to Reform the Banking Industry (2)  "Beyond Greed & Scarcity: An Interview with Be...